Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

:+fav:
 
©2009 *ta9mem
:iconta9mem:

Artist's Comments

NOW WHAT??

AM TIRED :(

Critiques


:iconinde-graphics:
first of all, if you want the mark of the logo ( 9 ) to be there, you have to alter it, make it more abstract as i see you tried, but it came out a legible letter, you must make it into a proper mark that makes people to want to look what happens there, not something neccesarily weird, just interesting enough. Now a word about the typography, i think that you must prove you are a designer here, make something up to date, get away from this serif version and let yourself design something new, something more interesting or something cleanner that just supports the mark. In any case make more interactions with the mark and type, i believe that the mark must support the type and level the result. Good luck with it. im a tough one but i can say you this... i was looking for a logo for me for about 3 years, i believe that it came to a good result, but this is purelly my belief, if you judje it, you may not like it.. its purelly getting on the wave saving yourself from falure, its all about innovative and functional risk!
The Artist thought this was FAIR
22 out of 23 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconarpad:
My first impression was that the top one works generally speaking, and so I give you a 2 star in "Vision".

Going deeper in the critique, I find the size ratio between the symbol and the typography a bit out of proportion. I would slightly reduce the symbol so it doesn't separate so much of the text in terms of attention: one is shouting hard while the other is whispering, even though the text is capitals only.

Except for the first mock-up, the disposition of elements is either cliché or naive (thus the half star in originality and technique).

I see a gap between the "spoken language" of the symbol and the text's. It is very hard to make a great logo using common serif fonts and numbers. Why don't you draw in your font? Give it a try, you'll see.

I like the overlay of the three 9's because it creates a certain visual distortion just like in those animation films which require special glasses. This is the reason why I give you a 3 star at impact, it stands out as the vibrant and preponderant element of the layout.

Overall, I think you have a long long way to run until you get a good, solid and memorable logo, and so I leave you with this piece of advice: try using a sans serif with non capital characters. Something that speaks the same language as the symbol, more fun, modern and at the same time with a couple of interesting details - finding some connections between the letters will add up in originality for sure.
The Artist thought this was FAIR
39 out of 40 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconantepli:
It is good to share your thoughts while you are thinking.

I feel you have a lot of power and creativity to add to this world.
:iconta9mem:
thnx .. bt really am tired frm my nick name ..
am straggling.. I dnt knw how 2 design a logo 4 me.. :(

which 1 u like the most?

--
Check my website - [link]
:iconantepli:
I liked number three, and I would re-scale the shape of 9 with the same horizon of the texts.

Good job, mashallah.

At the end, it is your touch, you are the artist.
:iconmshfar:
your making too many logos, keep this up and you will have trouble deciding..

keep it simple, you don't have to include (ta9mem) in it.. try to do one shape that explains it.

btw it is nice.. the third one feels professional

--
"Limits are there to help one grow, to achieve something in life" so says mshfar
:iconbodi002:
well done :)
i like the 9 shape
why not put it in the middl alone as a logo and then write the name down and the description down of the name
like this
....9
..TASMEM
..ID&;ph

--
••••
Pray as if it will be your last prayer
Work like you don't need money,
Love like you've never been hurt before and
Dance like nobody is watching
••••
:iconyousef:
go for the 3rd one :)

--
visit ==> [link]
:iconlistoric:
Best one is n03

but all of them aren't that good. The colors are boring and the shape is unsharp. It works if the picture is small, but as soon as you click on the thumbnail, the 9 is to unsharp.

Also, the font is not the best, and the subline, the "slogan" is hardly readable, even when the logo is big.

No 3 is best, but the 9 is too big. Also, the 9 is not a S, it's more like the letter g. 5 stands for S. So you have to tweak that also :)
:iconmongkih:
number 3 is the best one, number 1 looks nice but the pictorial logogram (9) seems too big and balanced up with the typo,
if you're about producing it thru an offset process, you might wanna reconsider those colors you used in your design :) it gonna cost you more :D, but this is only my opinion, it's all back to you and you idealism :D :hug:

--
hello world :)


am proud of ~indonesia

View Indonesia thru our vector art at ~V4I

Details

May 31
258 KB
62.8 KB
1024×1168

Statistics

20
6 [who?]
1,657 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map